The City of Whitehall?

What’s in a name? That which we call a rose
By any other name would smell as sweet.

Currently a township, Whitehall is considering the requirements and consequences for their designation as a city, and from the rapid growth in its population it looks like Allentown, Bethlehem and Easton may have a new member in the city-club of the region.

Whitehall is a first class township and is eligible to change their designation to third-class city after a voter referendum and a council change to their home charter rules. Their population, at the time of the 2010 census, was 26,738 just below Easton’s population of  26,800. Although their population nearly mirrors a neighboring city, there are other considerations in changing a municipality’s designation. There are many benefits in Pennsylvania to becoming a city. For example, only cities are eligible for certain tax incentive programs from the state like the Neighborhood Improvement Zone (NIZ) and the Community Revitalization Improvement Zone (CRIZ). Cities have more departments and authorities, like their own independent housing authority, which Whitehall Mayor Ed Hozza has said would be an important element to the now-township. The increase in size and scope of municipal government that comes with a change from township to city obviously isn’t free. The idea to change Whitehall into a city is still in its early stages and the cost to taxpayers is a major consideration right now.

The proposed change in Whitehall’s designation will hopefully spark an interesting conversation in Pennsylvania about the nearly unparalleled fragmentation and silo-like nature of the state’s local governance. The process of turning into a city may cause other municipalities to consider joining in a merger with Whitehall. The city of Bethlehem is the product of several borough mergers. Bethlehem was first formed in the Borough of South Bethlehem, a separate Borough of West Bethlehem. Decades later, the Borough of West Bethlehem joined with the Borough of Bethlehem (in Lehigh County). Finally, in the 20th century, the City of Bethlehem merged with the Borough of South Bethlehem to create the City of Bethlehem that we have today. Whitehall Township has several neighboring boroughs that may benefit from a merging with Whitehall Township to become the City of Whitehall. One such borough that could benefit is Coplay. With a population of under 5,000, a shared physical border and a combined school district, their merge makes sense and wouldn’t result in a decrease of services to Coplay residents. Another benefit to the merge is eligibility for a CRIZ. The CRIZ mandates a population over 30,000 which Whitehall Township doesn’t have on its own but would with the addition of Coplay residents.

If you’re a regular reader of the Renew Lehigh Valley blog here (which you should be!), you may have already heard of the hollowing out of the urban cores in our region as the population left cities in favor of new, sprawling second class townships. This was highlighted by a 2003 Brookings Report called Back to Prosperity. Some of the contributing research for this report detailed the excessive, small-box government that plagues Pennsylvania. There are 2,562 municipalities in the Keystone State each with their own municipal governing body. They range in size from 1.5 million in Philadelphia to the Borough of Centralia with 8 residents at the time of the 2010 Census.

In this state, they are broken down into cities, townships, boroughs and one town (Bloomsburg). Within those classifications there are first class cities (Philadelphia is the only one), second class cities (Scranton is the only one) and third class cities. There are first and second class townships and unclassified boroughs.

The Lehigh Valley alone has 62 municipalities (Northampton and Lehigh Counties). This fragmentation and duplication of efforts and services promotes sprawl and inhibits regionalism. Municipalities in Pennsylvania are permitted to create their own comprehensive plans and are not bound to formally adopt the regional comprehensive plan that is written by the Lehigh Valley Planning Commission. Changes in state policy that would encourage smaller municipalities to merge with their neighbors would increase the efficiency of service provision, minimize redundancies and create a more amenable environment for regional efforts.

Posted on August 9, 2013, in About RenewLV, Education, Housing, Municipal Government, Neighborhoods, Regions, State Policy, Trends, Urbanism. Bookmark the permalink. 3 Comments.

  1. Many township supervisors, borough council members, and public officials are disinclined to seriously consider consolidation or merger, at least partly because it would result in a loss of power or control, possibly even the loss of a job.

    How about an article or series that lays out the reasons how it would benefit them and why they should actively search for ways to make consolidation work?

    Of course, when issue like this are brought up in public hearings, we run into the all-too-familiar process of a lack of public awareness, incomplete or misleading information given to the public & community-based organizations, hearings at inconvenient times & places, superficial coverage by the media, and hearings where the conclusion is often virtually pre-determined. There is little or no real engagement of the public or their ideas, and if this isn’t done, the process is little more than an academic exercise.

    Envision LV made some dramatic advances in public engagement, with meetings in multiple locations, often with food and/or child care. Even this effort, though, has suffered from lack of effective outreach & inadequate time to explore issues that are complex and interdependent.

    What can RenewLV do to raise awareness of these issues in all areas of the population, generate effective outreach, and make sure that the pros & cons of consolidation are thoroughly explored and considered?

  2. Great points, Peter! We’ll look into your suggestions for a new blogpost, especially as Whitehall continues in this process.

    Unfortunately, EnvisionLV is tied to a brief 3 year timeline outlined in the Sustainable Communities Grant from US HUD. We hope to see public meetings on the Whitehall municipal change and discussions on a potential merger. They are very early in the process, but the consolidation would be an effort supported by Renew Lehigh Valley and we could take advantage of our media outlets to provide information.

  3. It is quite remarkable that Coplay has a police department while Lower Macungie Township takes advantage of the PA taxpayer.

    According to wiki, In 1867 Whitehall was apportioned from North and South Whitehall. Two years later, Coplay was incorporated, removing the 0.6 sq miles from Whitehall. Whitehall surrounds Coplay. Coplay and Whitehall also share a common sewer Authority and both communities recently passed referendums to support their libraries. Once folks can overcome their grip on days past, a merger could be a win-win for both communities. If a merger would happen, it would be best to initially maintain existing staff and then where efficiencies can be gain, changes could occur through attrition. I suspect each municipality could benefit from the energy and talent pool they have.

    For over 145 years, the villages of Stiles, Egypt, Cementon, Hockendaqua, Fullerton, Mickley, and West Catasauqua have survived and maintained their own identities and neighborly pride. I am sure Coplay could maintain its identity and community pride just like the other villages of Whitehall.

    I suspect the Commonwealth could provide incentives to convince communities to merge. Maybe it could build and equip a police department or maybe share the balance of pension obligations so financial obligation are equal upon merger.

    Envision provided a significant amount of seed money to Allentown, Bethlehem and Easton. I wonder if HUD would provide Envision an extension and fund such an initiative (merger and/or reclassification). Both initiives are in the spirt of sustainablity. It would be a great pilot project.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: